From the HSLDA E-lert Service:


2/13/2012 12:10:55 PM
Home School Legal Defense Association
HB 4309--ACTION NEEDED to Protect Families From Government Intrusion!

From the HSLDA E-lert Service...

HB 4309--ACTION NEEDED to Protect Families From Government Intrusion!

Dear West Virginia Members and Friends:

Thank you for your calls and emails that stopped HB 4309 from quick
passage. But the threat is not over. An education subcommittee will
meet February 20 at 2:00 p.m. to discuss a new version of the bill.
Both John Carey of Heritage Communications and I have been invited to
present to the subcommittee. It is our hope to convince the
committee that this legislation is not only unnecessary, but that it
is unconstitutional, and that the bill should be killed.

This legislation would give judges the ability to threaten families
with the removal of their children if children aren't in school enough
to satisfy a particular judge. This is as vague a statute as it is
breath- taking in its Orwellian attempt to circumvent existing law and
intimidate families who may accumulate more than five unexcused
absences--regardless of the reason. It is unacceptable to place this
kind of vague and overly broad authority in the hands of judges.

Here is what I plan to tell the committee on February 20:

"A law that sayschildren can be found abused and thereby removed from
their home, if they are 'presumed safe and otherwise healthy' but
'habitually absent for no good cause,' is on its face
unconstitutional. Merely being absent from school but otherwise safe
and healthy shows a lack of harm otherwise required to allow a state
to remove a child from parental care given that parents are guaranteed
under the 14th amendment the care, custody, and control of their

I know that the legislators and judges calling for this legislation
have good intentions. But we all know where the road paved with good
intentions leads. The reality is that West Virginia judges already
have all the authority they need to address habitual absence from
school, also known as truancy. HB 4309 is designed to give them more
power and permit them to ignore parents and go after children. This
bill threatens the most precious gift we all cherish--our children.
Tell the legislature to tell the judges to use the authority they
already have to address this problem.


The committee has now amended the bill, and it is appropriate for you
to re-contact them giving them the following message in your own

"Even amended, HB 4309 should not be passed--it is unnecessary, and
worse, is motivated by a philosophy that goes against our American
traditions of when the state should be able to act against parental
custody of children. This legislation is bad public policy and may be
unconstitutional. School districts and courts need to use the tools
they already have to address public school attendance problems. The
bill gives too much discretion to judges who are already overloaded.
The bill would also result in more families defending themselves in
Family Court where they have weaker due process protections and where
children can be taken away. Children who are safe and healthy should
not be taken from their families just because the children are not
going to school as often as a judge thinks is necessary. Please just
vote no on HB 4309."

Email string address (copy and paste into the "to", "cc" or "bcc"
block of an email--may not work for all email programs):;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;

Individual Committee Contact information:

Mary M. Poling - Chair
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3265
Business Phone: (304) 457-2206

Brady Paxton -vice chair (D - Putnam)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3337
Business Phone: (304) 340-3337

Walter E. Duke - minority Chair (R - Berkeley)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3151
Business Phone: (304) 582-4755

Linda Sumner (R - Raleigh)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3180
Business Phone: NA

Anthony Barill (D - Monongalia)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3173
Business Phone: NA

Denise L Campbell (D - Randolph)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3145
Business Phone: (304) 636-1391

Mike Caputo (D - Marion)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3249
Business Phone: (304) 363-7500

Kevin J. Craig (D - Cabell)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3350
Business Phone: (304) 522-5757

Gerald L. Crosier (D - Monroe)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3188
Business Phone: NA

Ron Fragale (D - Harrison)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3114
Business Phone: (304) 622-3609

Tiffany Elizabeth Lawrence (D - Jefferson)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3152
Business Phone: (304) 340-3152

Justin Marcum (D - Mingo)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3126
Business Phone: NA

Ricky Moye (D - Raleigh)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3162
Business Phone: (304) 255-2932

David G. Perry (D - Fayette)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3117
Business Phone: NA

Dave Pethtel (D - Wetzel)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3158
Business Phone: (304) 775-4221

Ralph Rodighiero (D - Logan)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3154
Business Phone: (304) 784-8881

Stan Shaver (D - Preston)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3146
Business Phone: (304) 568-2696

Margaret Donaldson Smith (D - Lewis)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3123
Business Phone: NA

Tim Armstead (R - Kanawha)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3240

Joe Ellington (R - Mercer)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3172
Business Phone: (304) 425-3800

Marty Gearheart (R - Mercer)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3179
Business Phone: (304) 320-0879

Amanda Pasdon (R - Monongalia)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3153
Business Phone: (304) 340-3153

Ruth Rowan (R - Hampshire)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3157
Business Phone: (304) 340-3157

Brian Savilla (R - Putnam)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3141
Business Phone: (304) 340-3141

Harold Sigler (R - Nicholas)
Capitol Phone: (304) 340-3143
Business Phone: (304) 651-3555


If passed HB 4309 would:

> Essentially define parents as child abusers if their children appear
physically healthy but miss what a judge thinks is too many days of

> Make it too easy for Child Protection Services and judges to remove
children from a home even if the children were not abused or

> Put too much power in the hands of unaccountable judges with vague
definitions and broad powers. What is habitually absent? Who defines
physically healthy?

> Result in the removal from their homes children who are having
non-physical problems, such as depression or other emotional issues,
and force them to attend public school against their parents' will;

> Affect homeschool families if they do not file their homeschool
paperwork properly, such as a late notice of intent or not complying
with the 14-day waiting period before pulling children out of public
school to homeschool;

> Not take into consideration children's special physical, mental,
emotional or other needs;

> Treat truancy as child abuse and place parents in Family Court were
the judges have virtually unlimited powers and where parents have
fewer due process protections;

> Create a system of enforcement that just does not care about the
individual needs of a child and the efforts that parents are putting
in to meeting those needs.

HB 4309 is unnecessary because state law already provides sufficient
authority to punish parents and for schools and attendance directors
to fashion remedies to deal with habitual truancy under the criminal

Thank you for taking action TODAY!

Without your support we could not stand for freedom in West Virginia!
If you or someone you know is not a member of HSLDA, will you consider
taking a moment today to join or recommend us and support our work
defending individual families threatened by government officials and
protecting homeschooling freedom for all? Join now at:

Mountaineers Always Free,

Michael P. Donnelly, Esq.
HSLDA Staff Attorney

-> "I saved my entire membership fee with one discount"

"When I called Liberty to find out what kind of discount we could
get, they told us we would 10% off our car insurance and 5% off
our homeowner's insurance. What we will save is more than double
what it costs to join HSLDA. With one child getting his driver's
license this year, the savings will be a real blessing!"

More reasons to join HSLDA...

The HSLDA E-lert Service is a service of:

Home School Legal Defense Association
P.O. Box 3000
Purcellville, Virginia 20134
Phone: (540) 338-5600
Fax: (540) 338-2733

How To Subscribe:

- Subscribe to the HSLDA E-lert Service at our website:

- Or send an email with name and complete mailing address to:

Subscription Information:

- You subscribed to the HSLDA E-lert Service as:


- To unsubscribe from the HSLDA E-lert Service send an email from
the email address you want to unsubscribe to:

- To change your email address or make other changes to your
subscription, visit the HSLDA E-lert Service account web page at:

POSTMASTERS: This message is being sent to the most recent address we
have for our subscribers. If this is an invalid email address or you
have other problems, please reply to
DISCLAIMER: This is considered a private and confidential message
from HSLDA to its bonafide HSLDA E-lert Service subscribers.
HSLDA cannot attest to the authenticity of copies posted, forwarded,
or sent by any party other than HSLDA.
NOTE: Please do not reply or otherwise use this email address; is for broadcast purposes only and is not intended to
receive incoming messages. We cannot reply to any email sent to this
address. If you have comments or questions, please send email to or call HSLDA at 540-338-5600. HSLDA members can also
email staff directly through the Members website at Thank you for your cooperation.