HSLDA Media Release
May 13, 1997

Private Schools Rally Against Public School Tests

For immediate release
May 13, 1997
Contact: Rich Jefferson
(540) 338-8663 or media@hslda.org

Private educators will rally outside the State House at noon on Thursday to oppose a bill that would impose a test of the public school curriculum on every private school in Massachusetts. Students across the Commonwealth are making banners for their private schools as they prepare to defend three and a half centuries of academic freedom.

     Rep. Harold Lane, Jr., House Chairman of the Joint Education Committee, sponsored House Bill 1886, which says, “The school committee shall administer the statewide assessment tests in private schools in their school district.” H1886 would mandate the new Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System (MCAS), which is designed to test whether students have mastered the new public school curriculum.

     The MCAS is Massachusetts’ expensive, experimental, and controversial new way of finding out whether the public schools are actually accomplishing what the citizens are paying for. Massachusetts has committed two billion dollars over seven years to fix public education. According to the department of education, 53 cents of every new tax dollar goes to fund “Ed. Reform,” as it is known. At least ten million of these dollars have been devoted to preparing the MCAS. The cost of administering it will be staggering, since the test requires three class sessions per subject, and there are seven subjects to be tested. This spring, students in the 4th, 8th, and 10th grades devoted ninety minutes to a try-out of just one subject. Eventually, public school students can expect to spend a full week of school on the MCAS. Private educators would rather teach their own curriculum for that week than take a test on the public school curriculum.

     “We can spend one day this week to preserve our liberty,” says Attorney Scott Somerville of the Home School Legal Defense Association (one of many groups opposing H1886), “or let them take away one week every year after we lose it.” When Ohio enacted similar legislation in 1993, private educators in that state were shocked when the federal courts refused to uphold any fundamental freedoms for secular private schools. Private educators in Massachusetts have learned from the bad example of Ohio, and hope a solid display of strength and unity on Thursday will protect their liberties.