Home School Legal Defense Association--25 Years of Serving the Homeschool Community





YOUR HOSTS


J. Michael Smith, Esq.
President


Michael P. Farris, Esq.
Chairman &
General Counsel





Click here to get Home School Heartbeat's daily e-mail transcripts

PREVIOUS PROGRAM
NEXT PROGRAM

Good News Is Hard to Believe
Listen Now
Volume 85, Program 10
10/3/2008

After the California Court of Appeal ruling that homeschooling was illegal in California, homeschoolers buckled in for a long, hard fight. On today’s Home School Heartbeat, HSLDA President Mike Smith and Jim Mason discuss why the recent reversal of that ruling was so surprising.

Mike Smith:
Jim Mason, HSLDA’s Senior Counsel, joins us today to discuss the California appeals court homeschooling victory. Jim, can you tell our listeners about why this case was reheard, and why the judges’ second decision was such a great surprise for the advocates for homeschooling?

Jim Mason:
Mike, when three longtime appeals court judges hand down a unanimous, landmark opinion, it is rare for them to agree to reconsider their own ruling. The justices agreed to do so in this case because their first opinion obviously failed to consider statutes that suggested their opinion might be wrong.

They not only agreed to reconsider their first opinion but also ordered completely new briefs about the legality of home education in California. These three justices also specifically invited several key public education agencies to file friend of the court briefs and indicated that they would welcome similar briefs from advocacy groups like HSLDA.

While all of this was very favorable indeed, it was still an uphill battle. Oral arguments in June took more than two hours. Based on the justices’ questions, it appeared that we needed to prepare for the worst.

But the Lord once again demonstrated His favor toward the homeschooling movement. The same three judges who had unequivocally ruled that homeschooling was illegal in February adopted all of the arguments favoring homeschooling in August.

Mike:
I join with you, Jim: we should applaud these three justices in being willing to reverse themselves. And until next time, I’m Mike Smith.


PREVIOUS PROGRAM
NEXT PROGRAM

Program Offer

Home School Legal Defense Association’s newsletter, The Home School Court Report, keeps you up-to-date on what's happening in legislatures and courtrooms around the nation, and reports on the latest studies and federal legislation affecting homeschoolers. Click the link above to request your sample copy of the latest issue, and stay informed about homeschooling!

Request Online



© Site Copyright 1996-2010 Home School Legal Defense Association
P.O. Box 3000 · Purcellville, VA 20134-9000 · Phone: (540) 338-5600 · Fax: (540) 338-2733 · E-mail: info@hslda.org

HOME | SEARCH | FEEDBACK | PRIVACY POLICY | USER AGREEMENT | ADVERTISING

Supported by the
Home School Foundation
Home School Foundation
www.homeschoolfoundation.org