Across the States
State Withdraws Remediation Demand
Can the state force a family into remediation if their 8th-grade student scores below the 30th percentile? This question recently tripped up the Iowa Department of Education.
Alan Clay (name changed to protect family’s privacy) was homeschooled under a supervising teacher for two years. For the 2007–2008 school year, however, his parents opted to drop the supervising teacher and submit a year-end assessment. This bright young man placed in the 96th percentile in reading, 84th percentile in language, 77th percentile in social studies, and 82nd percentile in science-excellent scores. In math, however, he scored only in the 27th percentile, three percentile points below the state minimum.
In many states, all subject scores are averaged before determining whether the test results meet the state requirement. In Iowa, however, a score below the 30th percentile in just one subject can bring down the hammer of remediation upon a young person with excellent scores in all other areas.
The family received a letter from the Iowa Department of Education telling them to submit an acceptable remediation plan or stop homeschooling Alan. Long-time members of Home School Legal Defense Association, the family called our legal department for help.
HSLDA Attorney Scott Woodruff reviewed the facts and realized that, although Alan had been under competent private instruction for three years, he was only subject to the annual assessment this last year. Iowa Administrative Code Regulation 31.7(1) states that “when a parent
provides private instruction to a child without the assistance or supervision of a validly licensed Iowa practitioner
the child is subject to initial baseline testing and an annual evaluation.” During Alan’s first two years of competent private instruction, he was not subject to an annual evaluation. His test at the end of the 2007–2008 school year was only a baseline. He was therefore not required to show progress or to achieve any particular score.
Woodruff placed a call to the staff person who had demanded remediation, suspecting that she had not first checked to see if Alan’s test was only a baseline. The department representative confirmed Woodruff’s suspicion and quickly agreed to withdraw the remediation demand, leaving the family free to determine the best way to meet
— by Scott A. Woodruff