Minnesota
HOME | LAWS | ORGANIZATIONS | CASES | LEGISLATION | HEADLINES | COMMON CORE
Minnesota

May 19, 2003

Senate File 99: Protecting Privacy of Homeschool Data

Sponsor:
Senator David L. Knutson (R), District 37.

Summary:
A companion bill to House File 168, Senate File 99 would solve Minnesota's data privacy problem by specifically stating that "data collected by a public school on a child that must be reported pursuant to Section 120A.24 is private data." "Private data" should be contrasted with "directory information" or "public data," which under Minnesota's Sunshine Law must be released upon request.

Status:
SF 99 was introduced to the Senate on January 23, 2003, and referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee. On Thursday, February 13, the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Data Practices unanimously passed SF 99.

The key language of SF 99 was added to several other bills. SF 99 itself had not progressed far when the 2003 regular session of the Minnesota Legislature adjourned on May 19, 2003. Fortunately, the data privacy language homeschoolers needed was added as an amendment to SF 10 of the 2003 1st special session, which passed both houses on May 22, 2003!

Action Requested:
None.

HSLDA's Position:
Support. We strongly encourage each member family and other friends of home education to contact the committee members listed above to urge them to pass this legislation.

Background:
Most Minnesota homeschoolers are aware of the privacy concerns that surfaced after the Department of Administration released Minnesota Advisory Opinion 00-052. It states homeschooled children are not "students," whose privacy falls under state and federal law. This means that a school district that released homeschool information "did not properly disseminate private educational data about" the homeschool student.

The new legislation would solve this problem by specifically stating that "data collected by a public school on a child that must be reported pursuant to Section 120A.24 is private data." "Private data" should be contrasted with "public data," which under Minnesota's Sunshine Law must be released upon request. In particular, homeschool information shall not be designated "directory information," which may be released to the public. "Directory information" typically includes name and address information for children enrolled in the public schools. It is often used by reporters for stories on student athletes, award winners, and so forth. The information is also used by the United States military for recruiting purposes, pursuant to federal law. Directory information is also available to direct mail marketers, and is one source of junk mail.

Under the new privacy bill, the information that homeschoolers and other private school families submit by October 1st each year is "private data," which shall not be designated "directory information" without prior written consent by the parents. The only exceptions to this privacy protection occur when data is released pursuant to a valid court order, a statute that specifically authorizes access to private data, or for bona fide public health concerns. (Since homeschooled students do not generally attend public educational agencies or institutions, this latter exception will rarely be invoked.)

 Other Resources

Bill Text

Bill History

2/5/2003 - Minnesota--New Legislation Would Protect Homeschool Privacy

2/11/2003 - Minnesota--Please Attend Hearing Scheduled on Homeschool Privacy Bill

2/14/2003 - Minnesota-Homeschool Privacy Bill Moves Forward